RetroSimba

Bob Forsch forgoes flash in joining strikeout leaders

July 27, 2011 by retrosimba

(Updated Aug. 5, 2023)

Among the top five on the Cardinals career strikeout list, one name stands out as a shining example of why persistence and reliability matter. Bob Forsch hardly was a strikeout artist, but he ranks with Bob Gibson, Adam Wainwright, Dizzy Dean and Chris Carpenter as being among the best in franchise history.

Of the top five strikeout pitchers among Cardinals, Forsch is the only one who never recorded as many as 190 strikeouts in a season. He never even came close.

In 15 seasons with the Cardinals, Forsch struck out 100 or more batters three times. His high was 114 in 1978. That also was the season he had his worst won-loss record with the Cardinals: 11-17.

The top Cardinals strikeout leaders are Gibson (3,117), Wainwright (2,186), Dean (1,095), Carpenter (1,085) and Forsch (1,079).

Gibson struck out 200 or more batters nine times. His career best was 274 in 1970. He led the National League with 268 in 1968. Gibson won the NL Cy Young Award in both years.

Dean achieved 190 or more strikeouts in five consecutive seasons: 1932 (191), 1933 (199), 1934 (195), 1935 (190) and 1936 (195). He led the NL for four consecutive years (1932-35).

Carpenter’s career high in strikeouts (213) helped earn him the Cy Young Award in 2005 with the Cardinals.

Wainwright had more than 200 strikeouts in a season three times: 212 in 2009, 213 in 2010 and 219 in 2013.

Forsch never led the Cardinals, let alone the NL, in strikeouts in any season.

Forsch’s single-game high in strikeouts came on April 12, 1978, in his second start of the season. Forsch pitched a complete-game four-hitter and struck out nine in the Cardinals’ 5-1 victory over the Pirates at St. Louis. In the ninth, the Pirates had two on with two outs when Forsch struck out third baseman Phil Garner with a hard slider for the third time to seal the win. Boxscore

“He was just showing us the fastball and going with a lot of off-speed stuff to get us out,” Pirates outfielder Dave Parker told the Associated Press.

Said Forsch to a reporter for United Press International: “I don’t think I gave in to anybody.”

Four days later, Forsch pitched the first of his two career no-hitters. On April 16, 1978, at St. Louis, Forsch struck out three and allowed no hits in the Cardinals’ 5-0 victory over the Phillies. Boxscore

(In his other no-hitter, Sept. 26, 1983, Forsch struck out six in the Cardinals’ 3-0 victory over the Expos at St. Louis. The sixth victim, pinch-hitter Terry Crowley, was ejected by umpire Harry Wendelstedt for arguing a called third strike leading off the ninth. Boxscore ).

Perhaps Forsch’s most dominant strikeout performance came against the Cubs on Sept. 20, 1987. Forsch started, pitched 5.2 innings before leaving with a groin strain and got the win in the Cardinals’ 10-2 victory over Greg Maddux in St. Louis. Of the 17 outs recorded by Forsch, eight were by strikeouts, an unusually high number for a 37-year-old right-hander better known for pitching to contact. Boxscore

Posted in Games, Pitchers, Records | 2 Comments »

1980s macho match: Whitey Herzog vs. Roger Craig

July 20, 2011 by retrosimba

(Updated July 22, 2019)

The intensity got turned up to maximum levels when Whitey Herzog managed the Cardinals against counterpart Roger Craig of the Giants.

On July 22, 1986, a scuffle involving the Cardinals and Giants in St. Louis was sparked by a war of words between Herzog and Craig.

The Cardinals, powered by an eight-run fourth inning, led, 10-2, in the bottom of the fifth when their speedster, Vince Coleman, swiped second and third.

After a walk to Ozzie Smith, reliever Juan Berenguer threw a wild pitch to Willie McGee. As Coleman broke for home plate, catcher Bob Melvin recovered the ball and threw to Berenguer, who applied a hard tag on Coleman. Berenguer voiced his displeasure with Coleman for stealing bases with his team ahead by eight runs.

When Coleman next batted in the seventh, reliever Frank Williams spun him away from the plate with an inside pitch. Umpire Bob Davidson issued a warning to both teams. With his next delivery, Williams hit Coleman in the left leg.

Herzog and Craig, a former Cardinals pitcher, had a heated exchange at home plate and “got shoves in as umpire John McSherry tried to restrain them,” the St. Louis Post-Dispatch reported. Craig accused Herzog of ordering Coleman to steal in order to embarrass the Giants.

“Whitey is a great manager,” Craig said to the San Francisco Examiner, “but I told him that was bush.”

Herzog told the Post-Dispatch, “I guess he thinks he invented the damn game or something.”

Both benches emptied and skirmishes broke out.

Giants pitcher Mike Krukow butted Coleman with his head and Coleman wrestled him to the ground, according to The Sporting News. When Giants utility player Joel Youngblood tackled Cardinals pitcher Ricky Horton, Herzog grabbed Youngblood by the neck. Giants infielder Randy Kutcher tried to pry Herzog off Youngblood, and Herzog tangled with Kutcher.

According to the Post-Dispatch, Herzog said to Kutcher: “Oh, you want some of me?”

Someone spiked Cardinals second baseman Tommy Herr in the face and neck. He needed eight stitches to close the wound.

Craig, Williams and Giants third baseman Chris Brown were ejected.

“It’s an outrage,” Herzog told the Associated Press. “I’m talking about Roger Craig. It’s bush league. If he wants us to stop running, he can send over a note promising to stop trying to hit home runs.”

Replied Craig: “I’m glad it happened. It showed me what (the Giants) are made of.”

The players followed the lead of their managers.

“Vince is going to run regardless of what point of the game we’re in,” Herr said. “That’s his game.”

Said Cardinals outfielder Any Van Slyke: “To throw at Vince for running is like throwing at Mickey Mantle for hitting home runs.”

Said Youngblood: “You never want to humiliate your opponent. If you do, you have to be prepared to accept the consequences. It’s almost like an unwritten rule. It’s baseball.”

Giants first baseman Bob Brenly said to the Post-Dispatch, “They were kicking the snot out of us. There was no need to rub it in. I feel (Coleman) was trying to show us up.”

Said Coleman: “I wasn’t there to show anybody up.”

The fracas seemed to inspire the Giants. After pulling to within three runs, 10-7, the Giants had two runners on base with two outs in the ninth before Todd Worrell got Candy Maldonado on a flyout to right. Boxscore and Video

“They had the tying run at the plate in the ninth,” Herzog told The Sporting News. “That’s why we run.”

Posted in Games, Managers, Opponents | 6 Comments »

Bob Gibson nearly was unbeatable against Mets

July 18, 2011 by retrosimba

From 1964 through 1966, Bob Gibson compiled a 12-1 record against the Mets. His only loss in that period was by the score of 1-0.

Gibson posted records against the Mets of 4-1 in 1964, 5-0 in 1965 and 3-0 in 1966.

Here is a look at Gibson’s wins in that stretch:

1964

Cardinals 5, Mets 1, May 9, at New York: Gibson had a shutout until catcher Jesse Gonder hit a home run in the eighth. Gibson, who improved to 3-0, also singled, walked and scored a run. Boxscore

Cardinals 3, Mets 1, July 10, at New York: After a RBI-single by Joe Christopher gave the Mets a 1-0 lead in the first, Gibson outdueled Jack Fisher. The Mets had one extra-base hit (a double by Ed Kranepool) and five singles. Boxscore

Cardinals 7, Mets 6, July 19, at St. Louis: The Cardinals erased a 6-3 Mets lead by scoring four runs in the ninth and salvaging a split of a Sunday doubleheader. Dick Groat’s RBI-single off Mets reliever Darrell Sutherland broke a 6-6 tie. Gibson struck out 11, including Gonder three times after the catcher belted a two-run homer in the first. Boxscore

Cardinals 11, Mets 5, Oct. 4, at St. Louis: Two days after Gibson had pitched eight innings in a 1-0 loss to Al Jackson and the Mets, the Cardinals entered the last day of the regular season in a first-place tie with the Reds. With St. Louis trailing 3-2 in the fifth, Gibson relieved Curt Simmons, pitched four innings, held New York to two hits and two runs, and earned the win. With the Reds losing 10-0 that day to the Phillies, St. Louis clinched its first pennant since 1946. Boxscore

1965

Cardinals 4, Mets 3, May 11, at New York: Warren Spahn, 44, was matched against Gibson, and the Mets staked the left-hander to a 3-0 lead through six innings. Sparked by Lou Brock’s two-run homer off Spahn, the Cardinals rallied, enabling Gibson to boost his record to 6-0 despite allowing 10 hits and six walks. Boxscore

Cardinals 6, Mets 3, July 2, at New York: Gibson struck out 13, matching what was then his career high. Twice, he struck out the side in order (in the second and in the fourth). Boxscore

Cardinals 8, Mets 5, July 16, at St. Louis: The Cardinals erased a 4-2 Mets lead with a six-run sixth. Gibson went seven innings and allowed four home runs. Charlie Smith, Jesse Gonder, Johnny Lewis and Jim Hickman all went deep for New York. Boxscore

Cardinals 8, Mets 1, Aug. 20, at New York: Gibson pitched a three-hitter and struck out 11. Charlie Smith’s homer accounted for the New York run. In the fifth, two innings after Gibson had hit Mets shortstop Roy McMillian with a pitcher, Al Jackson hit Gibson with a pitch. After advancing to second on a single, Gibson swiped third and scored on catcher Jimmie Schaffer’s throwing error. Boxscore

Cardinals 3, Mets 0, Sept. 5, at. St. Louis: In a Sunday doubleheader opener that lasted just 2:01, Gibson pitched a two-hit shutout. The Mets got singles by Johnny Lewis in the first and Joe Christopher in the fourth. After being held to one hit (an infield single by Curt Flood) through seven innings by Mets rookie starter Tug McGraw, the Cardinals struck for three unearned runs in the eighth. Boxscore

1966

Cardinals 5, Mets 4, April 21, at New York: Curt Flood’s two-run, two-out home run in the ninth off ex-Cardinal Gordon Richardson overcame a 4-3 New York lead before a Thursday afternoon gathering of only 4,261 at Shea Stadium. Gibson struck out 11 and held New York to one earned run on four hits. Boxscore

Cardinals 4, Mets 1, Aug. 7, at New York: Ed Kranepool’s eighth-inning homer was the only run against Gibson in the first game of a Sunday doubleheader. With one on and one out in the ninth, Hal Woodeshick relieved Gibson and got Cleon Jones to ground into a double play. Boxscore

Cardinals 9, Mets 6, Aug. 13, at St. Louis: The Cardinals built leads of 5-1 in the second and 8-3 in the sixth as Gibson cruised to his 15th win of the season. Gibson contributed a single and a stolen base. Boxscore

Posted in Games, Pitchers | Leave a Comment »

Carl Taylor, Roger Freed experienced the ultimate

July 16, 2011 by retrosimba

Carl Taylor and Roger Freed are the only Cardinals to achieve one of the rarest of big-league baseball feats: the ultimate grand slam, a game-ending, four-run home run that erases a three-run deficit with one swing.

Big thrill

Taylor, acquired by the Cardinals from the Pirates in October 1969 for pitcher Dave Giusti and catcher Dave Ricketts, was expected to compete for the starting right field position in 1970. Instead, the job went to Leron Lee and Taylor primarily was used as a pinch-hitter.

On Aug. 11, 1970, the Padres led the Cardinals, 10-7, in the ninth inning at St. Louis. With two outs, the bases loaded and pitcher Harry Parker due to bat, Cardinals manager Red Schoendienst sent in Taylor.

Padres reliever Ron Herbel delivered a thigh-high fastball and Taylor drove it about two feet beyond the left-field wall, giving the Cardinals an 11-10 victory.

“I figured he’d go to the fastball to try getting ahead of me,” Taylor told the Associated Press. “It’s got to be the biggest thrill I’ve ever had, because this one won the ballgame. Heck, it’s my first grand slam ever, even in Little League.”

It also was the last big-league homer Taylor would hit in a six-year career. Boxscore

“I hit the ball off the end of the bat,” Taylor told the St. Louis Post-Dispatch. “I thought it might be another one that would just reach the warning track. I hit a lot of those in batting practice, so many that the guys rib me about it.”

Making a contribution

Nine years later, on May 1, 1979, the Astros and Cardinals were involved in a see-saw game at St. Louis.

In the top of the 11th, with a 3-3 score, the Astros struck for three runs and led, 6-3.

Left-hander Joe Sambito loaded the bases with one out in the bottom half of the 11th, but when Garry Templeton struck out for the second out, the Cardinals’ hopes dimmed.

Jerry Mumphrey was due up next, and he hit right-handers better than he did left-handers, so manager Ken Boyer sent Freed to bat for him.

Freed, hitless in five at-bats that season, was keenly aware of reports his demotion to the minors could be imminent.

Sambito got ahead on the count, 1-and-2, but Freed worked the count back to his favor.

“My knees were shaking and sweat kept pouring into my eyes,” Freed told United Press International. “I asked the ump (Dave Pallone) for time and took a few deep breaths. I felt a bit strange because I’d only been up two or three times in the last three weeks.”

Freed launched Sambito’s 3-and-2 pitch over the left-field fence, giving the Cardinals a 7-6 victory. Boxscore

“This is the biggest, most pleasing experience anyone could have in a lifetime,” Freed said to the Post-Dispatch. “Something like this really makes me feel like a part of the ballclub, like I’m an asset to the team. You get to feeling like dead weight when you’re not contributing in some way.”

Freed said Sambito’s full-count pitch “was away, but out over the plate. I’m sure he got more of the plate, maybe four or five inches, than he wanted.”

Posted in Games, Hitters | 14 Comments »

Near no-hitter by Alan Benes became crushing loss

July 14, 2011 by retrosimba

(Updated May 16, 2020)

Halfway into May, the 1997 Cardinals had experienced much disappointment, including six consecutive losses to open the season and a mid-April stretch in which they never scored more than two runs in five straight games, but Alan Benes may have absorbed the cruelest blow of all.

Matched against Greg Maddux in a scoreless duel, Benes held the Braves hitless for 8.2 innings on May 16 in Atlanta until Michael Tucker doubled.

In the 13th, Tucker created more havoc when he scored from third on an infield dribbler by Andruw Jones off John Frascatore. Atlanta won, 1-0.

In command

Benes was 3-4 with a 3.08 ERA when he faced the defending National League champions. From the first pitch, he threw hard and with command. “All in all, it’s probably the best I’ve ever pitched,” Benes told the St. Louis Post-Dispatch.

The right-hander struck out 11 and walked three. After retiring the first two batters in the ninth, Benes threw a strike to Tucker, a left-handed batter. Tucker crushed the next pitch, a hanging breaking ball, for a double to left-center, ruining the no-hit bid.

“When the game gets into the late innings, you look for him to make a mistake and he did,” Tucker told the Post-Dispatch.

Benes struck out Fred McGriff to end the inning and turned the game over to the St. Louis bullpen.

“We feel terrible we couldn’t get him a run,” Cardinals outfielder Willie McGee said.

In his previous two starts, Benes lost by scores of 2-1 and 2-0.

Fluke hit

After Maddux held the Cardinals scoreless for eight innings, relievers Mark Wohlers, Mike Bielecki, Paul Byrd, Alan Embree, Brad Clontz and Joe Borowski combined to shut out St. Louis for five innings.

In the bottom of the 13th, Tucker singled versus Frascatore with one out, stole second and advanced to third on a flyout. McGriff was walked intentionally, bringing up Andruw Jones.

Jones told the Atlanta Constitution he thought T.J. Mathews, the pitcher he faced in the 11th inning, not Frascatore, was on the mound.

Fooled by Frascatore’s pitch, Jones checked his swing. The ball struck his bat and rolled slowly between the mound and first base. Tucker streaked across the plate as Jones reached first. “I was looking for a fastball, but he threw me a slider and I almost broke my wrist,” Jones said.

Said Cardinals manager Tony La Russa: “This is a really cruel way to lose. I’d rather lose any way than the way we did _ on a darned check swing.” Boxscore

According to the Atlanta Constitution, it was the first time the Braves won a 1-0, 13-inning game since May 26, 1959, when they beat Harvey Haddix of the Pirates after he pitched 12 perfect innings.

Benes’ older brother, Cardinals pitcher Andy Benes, told The Sporting News his sibling is “the type of guy who can go out and throw a no-hitter every five days because he throws the ball so hard and because of his breaking pitches.”

At the end of July, with a 9-9 record and 2.89 ERA, Alan Benes went on the disabled list because of a right shoulder injury. He sat out the remainder of the season, and all of the 1998 season, and never regained his peak form.

Posted in Games, Pitchers | 2 Comments »

#2,000: Hornsby, Musial, Slaughter, Brock all singled

July 12, 2011 by retrosimba

(Updated May 5, 2018)

On July 29, 2011, Albert Pujols became the first right-handed batter in 85 years to achieve 2,000 hits as a Cardinal. Pujols got his 2,000th hit, a double, against Cubs reliever Carlos Marmol.

Pujols became the fifth player to collect 2,000 hits as a Cardinal. Pujols finished his Cardinals career with 2,073 hits before becoming a free agent and joining the Angels after the 2011 World Series.

Stan Musial (3,630), Lou Brock (2,713), Rogers Hornsby (2,110) and Enos Slaughter (2,064) also achieved 2,000 hits as Cardinals. Of those four, only Musial played his entire big-league career with St. Louis. The career hit totals of the others: Brock (3,023), Hornsby (2,930) and Slaughter (2,383). Pujols achieved his 3,000th career hit on May 4, 2018.

Here is a look at the 2,000th Cardinals hit for each of the four who achieved the feat before Pujols did:

ROGERS HORNSBY

At age 30, Hornsby became both the youngest and the first to reach 2,000 hits as a Cardinal.

The player-manager achieved the milestone with a single against Don Songer of the Pirates on June 23, 1926, at St. Louis.

Hornsby, playing second base and batting third, received greater attention for his 2,001st hit _ a grand slam off Songer in the seventh inning, lifting St. Louis to a 6-2 victory. Boxscore

The Cardinals, who entered the game in third place, went on to win the pennant and their first World Series title that year.

STAN MUSIAL

With a fourth-inning single against the Phillies’ Curt Simmons on Sept. 9, 1952, at Philadelphia, Musial became the first of three left-handed batters to achieve 2,000 hits as a Cardinal.

Batting third and playing first base, it was Musial’s only hit in five at-bats that Tuesday night, but it extended his hitting streak to 14 games. The Cardinals overcame a 4-2 deficit with a five-run ninth inning, winning 7-4. Boxscore

Musial, 31, went on to earn his sixth National League batting championship (.336) that season.

ENOS SLAUGHTER

In his last season with St. Louis, Slaughter, 37, still was a productive everyday player.

Batting cleanup and playing right field, Slaughter’s 2,000th hit as a Cardinal was a RBI-single that scored Red Schoendienst from second, snapped a 2-2 tie in the third and knocked out Dodgers starter Russ Meyer on July 18, 1953, at Brooklyn. The Dodgers erupted for nine runs in the fourth and won, 14-6. Boxscore

The loss was the sixth in a row for the Cardinals, who fell eight games behind the first-place Dodgers. Slaughter was traded to the Yankees the following April.

LOU BROCK

In 1974, Brock, 35, seemed to set a record a day for the Cardinals.

On July 28, 1974, his leadoff single in the seventh inning against Cubs reliever Oscar Zamora gave the left fielder his 2,000 hit as a Cardinal. St. Louis scored a run in the eighth to tie and another in the ninth to win, 5-4, at Chicago. Boxscore

The next day, Brock stole his 700th career base in a game the Cardinals won, 11-4, against the Cubs. Boxscore

Watching Brock excel had to be torment for Chicago. Brock began his big-league career with the Cubs in 1961 and had 310 hits for them before being traded to St. Louis in June 1964.

Brock achieved his 2,000th major-league hit _ a single against Larry Gura of the Cubs to lead off the 15th inning _ on Sept. 30, 1972, at Chicago. The Cardinals won, 2-1, in 16. Boxscore

As a Cardinal, Brock batted a career-best .334 against the Cubs, with 342 hits and 103 RBI.

Posted in Games, Hitters, Records | 3 Comments »

« Newer Posts - Older Posts »