RetroSimba

With Ron Santo in Hall, Ken Boyer should be there, too

December 8, 2010 by retrosimba

(Updated on Sept. 13, 2025)

In 2011, a committee elected Ron Santo to the National Baseball Hall of Fame.

Santo, former Cubs third baseman, was deserving of election, but voters should do the right thing and elect former Cardinals third baseman Ken Boyer, too. To elect one without the other is an injustice.

The 16-person committee failed to elect Boyer when it met in 2011 and again in 2014, 2021 and 2024.

The committee considers players whose primes were between 1950 and 1969. Boyer and Santo each won the Gold Glove Award five times (Boyer, 1958, 1959, 1960, 1961 and 1963; Santo, 1964, 1965, 1966, 1967 and 1968).

Both were equals as fielders. The same was true as hitters.

Some give Santo the edge because he had more career home runs and RBI than Boyer, but Santo also had almost 700 more at-bats (8,143 for Santo and 7,455 for Boyer). The career numbers:

BOYER: .287 batting average, 2,143 hits, 282 HR, 1,141 RBI.

SANTO: .277 batting average, 2,254 hits, 342 HR, 1,331 RBI.

Santo (.362) had a higher on-base percentage than Boyer (.349) and their slugging percentages were nearly equal _ .464 for Santo and .462 for Boyer.

In June 1963, Cardinals consultant Branch Rickey, generally considered a top evaluator of talent, told The Sporting News that Boyer is “the best third baseman in baseball today, with the bat, the arm and the legs. He’s the most underrated fielder. Take his bat away and this big fellow still is a great third baseman.”

A cover story by Dave Anderson in the 1965 season preview edition of Dell Sports magazine captured how highly regarded Boyer was during his prime. Boyer was named winner of the National League Most Valuable Player Award in 1964 when he led the Cardinals to the World Series championship. (Santo never played in a World Series.) Dell Sports assigned Anderson to do a piece about Boyer and the Orioles’ Brooks Robinson, with the angle that the duo might be the best third basemen of all-time.

“Take a good look this season at Ken Boyer and Brooks Robinson,” Anderson wrote. “Appreciate them now, while they’re at their peak. They’re two of the best third basemen in baseball history. Possibly the best ever. Surely they’re the two best ever to compete in the same era.

“Many old-timers consider it heresy to rate any of the current stars as the best ever at their positions, but Ken Boyer of the St. Louis Cardinals and Brooks Robinson of the Baltimore Orioles demand such recognition. None of the other current stars have invaded the history of their position the way Boyer and Robinson have at third base.”

Anderson interviewed former Pirates third baseman Pie Traynor, who was elected to the Hall of Fame in 1948 after excelling as a fielder and hitter (.320 batting average) from 1920-37.

Traynor told Anderson, “Boyer is a steady, great ballplayer. He’s the punch of the Cardinals. If he doesn’t drive in all those runs (119 in 1964), they don’t win the pennant last season, and if he doesn’t drive in runs in the World Series, they don’t win that.”

When Anderson noted Boyer had put together 10 spectacularly steady seasons, Traynor replied, “(Brooks) Robinson must do that. He had a big season last year (1964), but can he keep it up like Boyer?”

Robinson did have a wonderful career with Baltimore and was elected to the Hall of Fame in 1983, one year after Boyer died of cancer at 51.

In the book “Few and Chosen,” Ken Boyer’s brother, Clete Boyer, who played in five World Series during eight years with the Yankees, said, “If we changed places and Ken played in New York (during his prime), he’d be in the Hall of Fame.”

Posted in Hitters | 10 Comments »

Here’s how Bob Uecker helped Cardinals to 1964 title

December 3, 2010 by retrosimba

(Updated Sept. 27, 2019)

Bob Uecker, unable to supplant Joe Torre as the starting catcher, was traded by the Braves to the Cardinals for outfielder Gary Kolb and catcher Jim Coker on April 9, 1964.

bob_uecker The Cardinals needed a backup for Tim McCarver and they liked Uecker’s throwing arm.

“We got Uecker to help Timmy and make our catching solid,” St. Louis manager Johnny Keane told The Sporting News. “We’re certainly not vulnerable behind the plate anymore. Our bench could be stronger, too, with Uecker available.”

Though Uecker, 29, was used sparingly during the season, he strongly contributed to a significant win against his former team in the Cardinals’ late surge to the 1964 National League pennant.

On Sept. 1, 1964, in a game at St. Louis, the Braves took a 4-0 lead in the second inning against the Cardinals and knocked out starter Ray Sadecki. Behind the relief pitching of Ron Taylor, the Cardinals fought back. Uecker hit his only home run of the season, a solo shot in the fourth off Denny Lemaster, to get the Cardinals within a run at 4-3.

In the bottom of the ninth, with the score tied at 4-4, Julian Javier laced a one-out double and Lemaster intentionally walked Carl Warwick to get to Uecker, hoping to induce a double play.

Uecker, who hit .198 that season, foiled the strategy by pulling a single to left, scoring Javier from second and giving the Cardinals a 5-4 walkoff victory. Boxscore

“I wasn’t trying extra hard just because we were playing the Braves,” Uecker said to the St. Louis Post-Dispatch. “I was just happy to get some hits. I’d been hitting the ball good, but right at somebody.”

In the clubhouse after the game, as Uecker waited to be interviewed on television, his road roommate, pitcher Roger Craig, playfully approached him with a handful of shaving cream and a razor. “You’ve got to look right when you’re going on television,” Craig said to Uecker.

Spurred by the comeback, the Cardinals posted a 21-8 record in September, clinched the pennant on the final day of the regular season and won the World Series championship in a seven-game classic with the Yankees.

In his 1987 book, “Oh, Baby, I Love It,” McCarver recalled the scene in the clubhouse after the Cardinals beat the Yankees in Game 7 of the 1964 World Series: “I remember Bob Uecker, without a stitch of clothing on, dancing to the dumbest song I’d ever heard _ ‘Pass the Biscuits, Miranda.’ He was dancing all by himself, somehow putting modern moves to this idiotic song that, for some reason, had been the 1946 Cardinals’ rallying song. Uke could dance, too.”

Uecker was McCarver’s backup again in 1965, batting .228 in 53 games. Uecker hit two homers that season, against future Hall of Famers Gaylord Perry of the Giants and Sandy Koufax of the Dodgers.

On Oct. 27, 1965, the Cardinals traded first baseman Bill White, shortstop Dick Groat and Uecker to Philadelphia for outfielder Alex Johnson, pitcher Art Mahaffey and catcher Pat Corrales.

In his book “The Spirit of St. Louis,” author Peter Golenbock said Uecker was traded because he routinely entertained his teammates with humorous imitations of Cardinals general manager Bob Howsam, who wasn’t amused.

Howsam also was a protege of Branch Rickey, who had opposed the deal that brought Uecker to the Cardinals.

“When it came time to deal Bill White to the Phils,” Golenbock wrote, “Howsam refused to OK the trade unless Philadelphia accepted Uecker as well. For Howsam, it was addition by subtraction.”

Posted in Broadcasters, Hitters | 7 Comments »

Tom Underwood was key in major Cardinals trades

November 29, 2010 by retrosimba

Tom Underwood’s time with the Cardinals was brief _ 19 games pitched in 1977 _ but he was an integral part of two trades that significantly shaped the St. Louis team.

A left-handed pitcher, Underwood was the centerpiece of a controversial trade by the Cardinals that sent outfielder Bake McBride and pitcher Steve Waterbury to the Phillies on June 15, 1977. In addition to Underwood, the Cardinals got outfielders Dane Iorg and Rick Bosetti.

McBride was popular with Cardinals fans and players, but he feuded with first-year St. Louis manager Vern Rapp. McBride was the first Cardinal to defy Rapp’s hair-length code and he bristled at Rapp’s demand that McBride trim his mutton chop sideburns.

Because McBride had undergone knee surgery in 1976, Rapp wanted to move him from center field to right field and place Tony Scott in center. When McBride balked at the move, it triggered the trade to Philadelphia.

The Cubs thought they had a deal to acquire Underwood from the Phillies for outfielders Jose Cardenal and Greg Gross. When the Cardinals made McBride available, the Phillies dealt with St. Louis instead.

McBride, who batted .307 in five years with St. Louis, helped the Phillies to three division titles and the 1980 World Series championship.

Underwood was 6-9 with a 4.95 ERA (17 starts, two relief appearances) with St. Louis. He walked (57) almost as many as he struck out (66).

The Cardinals wanted Underwood because their only left-handed starter, Pete Falcone, was struggling and two other rotation members (Larry Dierker and John Denny) were slowed by injuries. At the time of the trade, Underwood was 23 and coming off consecutive winning seasons for the Phillies. The Cardinals envisioned him as a pitcher who could pay dividends for years.

As a Cardinal, Underwood was effective against left-handed batters (he held them to a .186 batting average with no home runs). Right-handed batters pounded him for a .299 batting average and seven homers.

In his nine losses with St. Louis, Underwood had a 7.82 ERA and opponents batted .363 against him.

Underwood’s best-pitched game for the Cardinals came against the Cubs in Wrigley Field on Sept. 6, 1977. He pitched a complete game, yielding six hits and a run while striking out eight in a 3-1 Cardinals victory. Catcher Ted Simmons homered, singled, walked, scored a run and drove in two. Boxscore

On Dec. 6, 1977, Underwood and picher Victor Cruz were traded by the Cardinals to the Blue Jays for pitcher Pete Vuckovich and outfielder John Scott.

Vuckovich, a tough right-hander, pitched well (39-31, 3.21 ERA) in three years with St. Louis. He, along with Simmons and reliever Rollie Fingers, were dealt by the Cardinals to the Brewers in December 1980 for pitchers Dave LaPoint and Lary Sorensen and outfielders David Green and Sixto Lezcano. That trade was critical to the construction of the Cardinals and Brewers into pennant winners in 1982.

Underwood went on to pitch for the Blue Jays, Yankees, Athletics and Orioles. In an 11-year big-league career, he was 86-87 with a 3.89 ERA.

Posted in Pitchers, Trades | 2 Comments »

Ted Simmons caught no-hitter by Bob Gibson

November 26, 2010 by retrosimba

(Updated Nov. 25, 2019)

On Aug. 14, 1971, a Saturday night in Pittsburgh, Ted Simmons caught Bob Gibson’s no-hitter, produced four hits, scored three runs and drove in one in the Cardinals’ 11-0 victory. Boxscore

It was the only no-hitter in the career of the franchise’s best pitcher.

Simmons became the only catcher in franchise history to collect four hits while catching a no-hitter.

Simmons’ performance went a long way toward validating him as a quality catcher in the view of Gibson and others.

In control

Since early in his career, when he surrended a home run on a fastball he was ordered to throw by Carl Sawatski, Gibson never again let a catcher select a pitch for him.

“When I want to throw a pitch, that’s what I’m going to throw,” Gibson said in the book “Sixty Feet, Six Inches.” “If the catcher wants to fight about it, we’ll fight about it, but I’m not going to throw something I don’t want to throw.”

Regarding the pitcher and catcher relationship, Gibson said he believed the player with the most experience should “take the lead” in controlling a game. With Simmons, that meant Gibson always was in charge.

“Ted Simmons used to drive me crazy when he was a young catcher,” Gibson said. “One day he called time and came out to ask if I was giving him a hard time … I said, ‘I’m trying to win the ballgame. I don’t have the luxury of giving you a hard time.’ ”

Simmons caught 135 of Gibson’s starts. Only Tim McCarver (197) caught more. Simmons also caught 13 of Gibson’s shutouts. McCarver caught the most, 29.

“Simmons was a bright guy and he learned,” Gibson said. “It took him a while, but he caught on. As a rookie, all he thought about was hitting line drives, which he did very well. You can forgive a catcher for a lot of sins when he clears the bases with a double.”

In a June 1973 article by Bob Broeg for Baseball Digest, Simmons said, “Gibson is a picnic to catch because he works rapidly and is always around the plate with his pitches.”

In a November 2019 interview with Cardinals broadcaster Dan McLaughlin, Simmons recalled having trouble giving signs in his early encounters with Gibson.

“I was having difficulty, frankly,” Simmons said. “I’d never seen a guy pitch at that pace with such great stuff. So, trying just to get the fingers down and coordinate it throughout the game was a task for me.

“Finally, Gibson came to me and said, ‘Look, I only throw two pitches _ fastball, slider. You put down whatever you want. If I’m shaking, go to the other.’ So, if I put down fastball and he was shaking his head, I knew the pitch was going to be slider. That way, I wasn’t disrupting his pace.”

Heat is on

In his no-hitter against the Pirates _ the first in Pittsburgh since 1907 _ Gibson struck out 10 and walked three.

“He had two unhittable pitches (fastball and slider) and they couldn’t hit either one,” Simmons recalled in a 2020 interview with Stan McNeal of Cardinals Gameday Magazine.

Simmons contributed a RBI-single off Bob Johnson in the first, a double against Bob Moose in the fifth, and singles in the sixth and eighth off Bob Veale.

When Pirates slugger Willie Stargell struck out looking for the final out, Simmons raced to the mound, leaped and threw his arms around Gibson’s neck.

“That was the greatest thrill of my life, catching a no-hitter,” Simmons said to the St. Louis Post-Dispatch. “Man, he was throwing fire.”

Simmons had a premonition Gibson would get the no-hitter against the Pirates.

“Two nights ago, (teammate) Chris Zachary and I were having dinner, and I told him, ‘Gibson is going to pitch a no-hitter Saturday night,’ ” Simmons said. “I don’t know why, I just said it.”

Posted in Games, Hitters, Pitchers | 1 Comment »

Stan Musial shared a special bond with JFK

November 19, 2010 by retrosimba

(Updated Nov. 17, 2019)

On Nov. 17, 2010, four days before his 90th birthday, Stan Musial got an early gift with the White House announcement that he would be awarded the Presidential Medal of Freedom in 2011.

The greatest Cardinals player deserved the honor for many reasons. What made it extra special was the connection the award had to President John F. Kennedy.

President Harry Truman established the award in 1945 to honor exceptional World War II service. Kennedy reintroduced the award in 1963 to recognize civilian achievement.

Musial and Kennedy bonded during the 1962 All-Star Game in Washington, D.C.

Before the game, JFK summoned Musial to his box seat at D.C. Stadium. Musial reminded the president they first met in September 1959 when Senator Kennedy was campaigning in Milwaukee for the 1960 Democratic presidential nomination.

“I was standing in front of the hotel, waiting for the bus for the game,” Musial told Joe King of The Sporting News, “and a man came up to me and said, ‘You are Stan Musial and I’m glad to meet you. I’m Jack Kennedy.’

“Of course I knew him,” Musial said. “And then he said, ‘You’re too old to play ball and I’m too young to be president, but maybe we’ll fool ’em.’

“I reminded the President of that remark when I went over to visit him, and he said he thought both of us probably were doing a good job.”

Musial, 41, appearing in his 22nd All-Star Game, batted for pitcher Juan Marichal in the sixth inning and lined a single to right on a two-strike curve from Camilo Pascual. Maury Wills ran for Musial, swiped second and scored the first run of the game on Dick Groat’s single. The National League won, 3-1.

Musial, wife Lillian and daughter Janet were given a VIP tour of the White House the next day and met with Kennedy.

The president presented Musial with a PT 109 tie pin and an autographed picture.

According to a report by The Sporting News, Kennedy and Musial talked baseball. Musial was asked about his home run total and whether he would surpass Ty Cobb for the all-time hits record.

When Musial was congratulated by White House staffers for his single in the All-Star Game, he replied, “I got a bigger kick out of the handshake with the President before the game.”

Told that Kennedy applauded his hit, Musial said with a smile, “The President is my buddy. When I shook hands with him, he told the people in his party what a good job of campaigning I did for him.”

In January 1964, after his retirement, Musial was named by President Lyndon Johnson as special consultant to the President’s Council on Physical Fitness, a program started in 1956 by President Dwight Eisenhower and popularized during the term of the youthful President Kennedy.

Posted in Games, Hitters | 2 Comments »

Ted Simmons feels accepted as St. Louis legend

November 18, 2010 by retrosimba

Former Cardinals catcher Ted Simmons was inducted into the St. Louis Sports Hall of Fame on Nov. 16, 2010. Before a crowd of 1,500 at a downtown St. Louis hotel, Simmons was part of the hall’s second induction class, joining former Cardinals pitcher Dizzy Dean and former Browns first baseman George Sisler.

Simmons told the St. Louis Post-Dispatch the honor was “staggering.”

He also was interviewed by television station KSDK. Among the highlights of the KSDK interview:

_ Asked about his approach to hitting and why he became known for line drives, Simmons said he adopted a stroke similar to teammate Matty Alou by making a “top down” swing on pitches and trying to avoid hitting high fly balls into the spacious outfield of Busch Stadium.

_ Regarding the St. Louis Hall of Fame induction, Simmons said “it means I’ve basically been accepted in this community after being here for 35 years.” He called it “a very special honor for me.”

Simmons also concluded his first season as manager of the Peoria Saguaros in the Arizona Fall League, an experience that enhanced his reputation as a talent evaluator.

In an article by Jack Magruder of FOXSportsArizona.com, Simmons talked about his first managerial effort and how much he enjoyed working from the third-base coaching box while his team was at bat.

Among those interviewed for the article was Kevin Towers, general manager of the Diamondbacks, who said of Simmons, “He has a great baseball mind, an incredible baseball mind … He’s a good man. Very loyal. Tough.”

Posted in Hitters, Managers | Leave a Comment »

« Newer Posts - Older Posts »