While growing up in the St. Louis suburb of University City, Ken Holtzman rooted for the Cardinals and dreamed of pitching in the big leagues. Holtzman got to the majors, but not with the Cardinals. He went instead to their rivals, the Cubs.
A left-hander, Holtzman was a starter for the Athletics when they won three consecutive World Series titles. He also pitched two no-hitters in the National League and, as a rookie, beat his boyhood baseball idol, giving Sandy Koufax his last regular-season career loss.
When he pitched the last game of his 15-year stint in the majors, it occurred, fittingly, in his hometown against the Cardinals. Afterward, Holtzman told the St. Louis Post-Dispatch, “Even though I signed to play with the Cubs, my heart has always been with the Cardinals.”
Holtzman achieved 174 regular-season wins and four more in the World Series. He was 78 when he died on April 14, 2024.
Natural talent
Holtzman got his interest in baseball from his father, Henry, a machine tool dealer.
“I remember reading Jimmy Piersall’s book and how his father pushed him,” Holtzman recalled to The Sporting News. “It was nothing like that with my dad. He didn’t push me, but he used to encourage me.
“He would try to keep my mind preoccupied with sports, and especially improving myself as far as baseball was concerned. When other kids would be thinking about girls and cars after school hours, I used to go home and my father would be waiting. He would take time out from his own business. We’d go over to a park a few blocks away. He’d hit me fly balls and I’d pitch to him. He recognized I had a natural talent for baseball, but we actually worked on all sports. Pretty soon I developed my own desire to improve myself.”
Holtzman was 8 when his dad took him to his first big-league game at the former Sportsman’s Park in St. Louis. “When we walked into the old park, I thought it was the greatest thing in the world,” Holtzman told the Post-Dispatch.
As a pitcher for University City High School, Holtzman was coached during his sophomore and junior years by Ed Mickelson, a former first baseman for the Cardinals, Browns and Cubs. Mickelson’s replacement, Henry Buffa, coached University City to a state title in Holtzman’s senior year of 1963. Holtzman pitched a no-hitter and struck out 14 in the state semifinal against Springfield Hillcrest.
After his sophomore season at the University of Illinois, the Cubs chose Holtzman in the fourth round of the June 1965 amateur draft. Pitching for farm clubs, Holtzman, 19, struck out 114 in 86 innings that summer, earning a promotion to the Cubs in September. The first pitch he threw for them was walloped by the Giants’ Jim Ray Hart for a home run. Boxscore
Special games
Holtzman arranged to take classes at the University of Illinois branch campus in Chicago while pitching for the Cubs.
The first time he faced the Cardinals was on May 25, 1966, in the sixth game played at Busch Memorial Stadium in St. Louis. Several Holtzman family members were there to cheer him. “I was a little nervous at first,” Holtzman said to the Post-Dispatch. “My grandmother was seeing her first major-league game.”
Holtzman pitched well, allowing two runs in six innings, but was the losing pitcher. Boxscore
Afterward, Holtzman took a 12:19 a.m. flight to Chicago because he had an 8 a.m. French class to attend, the Post-Dispatch reported.
The next time Holtzman pitched in St. Louis, on July 17, 1966, he got the win, yielding two runs in seven innings. Two future Hall of Famers supported him. Ferguson Jenkins got the save and Billy Williams hit for the cycle. Boxscore
Some saw Holtzman, 20, as the Cubs’ version of Sandy Koufax.
“Sportswriters made the first comparison between Sandy and me, primarily, I guess, because both of us are left-handers and Jewish,” Holtzman told The Sporting News. “As far as I’m concerned, there is no comparison. He was my boyhood idol and I still regard him as the greatest I’ve ever seen. We’re miles and miles apart.”
The only time Holtzman and Koufax started against one another was on Sept. 25, 1966, at Wrigley Field in Chicago. Holtzman won, holding the Dodgers hitless until Dick Schofield led off the ninth with a single.
The pitching lines:
_ Koufax: 8 innings, 4 hits, 2 runs (one earned), 2 walks, 5 strikeouts.
_ Holtzman: 9 innings, 2 hits, 1 run, 2 walks, 8 strikeouts.
“It isn’t often Koufax loses when he holds a team to one earned run and four hits,” the Los Angeles Times noted, “but this time he was outpitched by Holtzman.”
Koufax told the newspaper, “When a guy holds you hitless for eight innings, you know he pitched a great game. I was satisfied with my performance, but Ken was too good for us today.” Boxscore
On the rise
Limited to 12 starts for the Cubs in 1967 because of military duty, Holtzman was 9-0, including a win against the Cardinals, who were on their way to becoming World Series champions. Boxscore
Holtzman also earned his degree in business administration from Illinois in 1967. He worked several winters for I.M. Simon and Company, a St. Louis securities brokerage firm, and earned accreditation from the New York Stock Exchange as a registered representative.
On Aug. 2, 1968, Holtzman pitched his third consecutive shutout, a two-hitter against the Cardinals. Using a changeup and a fastball, he limited St. Louis to singles by Julian Javier and Tim McCarver. “I feel it was the best game I ever pitched,” Holtzman said to the Post-Dispatch. “I may have had better stuff in some other game, but I think that as far as smartness and strategy, this was my best. I felt in command all the way.” Boxscore
Holtzman pitched no-hitters against the Braves (in 1969) and the Reds (in 1971), but the Cardinals gave him trouble. He was 9-14 against them. Lou Brock beat him with a walkoff home run in 1969. Boxscore Joe Torre, in 74 plate appearances versus Holtzman, had a .554 on-base percentage and .508 batting average.
After consecutive 17-win seasons in 1969 and 1970, Holtzman was 9-15 in 1971, had differences with Cubs manager Leo Durocher and sought to be traded. On Nov. 29, 1971, the Cubs dealt Holtzman to the Athletics for Rick Monday. “I wouldn’t have cared if the Cubs had traded me for two dozen eggs,” Holtzman told the Chicago Tribune.
American Leaguer
The four years Holtzman spent with the Athletics were the glory days of his career. The club won three consecutive World Series titles. Holtzman’s regular-season win totals were 19 in 1972, 21 in 1973, 19 again in 1974 and 18 in 1975.
On the eve of the 1972 World Series, Athletics manager Dick Williams said to the Oakland Tribune, “Ken has pitched superbly for us all year. You might say he saved us. Without those 19 wins, the only way the A’s would have made the World Series is by paying to get in.”
Holtzman was 4-1 in World Series games for the Athletics and hit .333, with a home run and three doubles. Video
On April 2, 1976, Holtzman and Reggie Jackson were traded to the Orioles for Don Baylor, Paul Mitchell and Mike Torrez. Two months later, Holtzman was flipped to the Yankees. He was 9-7 for them but fell into disfavor with manager Billy Martin, who didn’t use him in the playoffs or World Series that year.
Though Holtzman was healthy, Martin rarely pitched him in 1977. He worked 71.2 innings, a pittance for a pitcher who exceeded 200 innings nine times. The New York Times dubbed him the “designated sitter” and noted, “It is very likely that Holtzman sits simply because the manager doesn’t have confidence in him.”
Ignored again in 1978, Holtzman asked out and was sent to the Cubs in June.
Headed for home
The rust took a toll on Holtzman. His ERA with the 1978 Cubs was 6.11. He was better in 1979, shutting out the Astros twice, but as the season wound down he knew it would be his last.
His final big-league appearance on Sept. 19, 1979, was a start at St. Louis. Holtzman held the Cardinals scoreless. In the seventh, with two outs, a runner on base and Ted Simmons batting, Cubs manager Herman Franks wanted to lift Holtzman, but he didn’t want to leave. “I told Herman I wanted to pitch to one more man,” Holtzman said to the Post-Dispatch.
Franks relented and Holtzman retired Simmons, ending the inning. “Simmons is the best,” Holtzman told the Post-Dispatch. “At least I went out beating the best.”
After Bill Buckner batted for Holtzman in the eighth, Bruce Sutter took a 2-0 lead into the bottom of the ninth but blew the save chance, costing Holtzman a win. Boxscore
Holtzman settled in Chicago, earned a master’s degree in education at DePaul and taught in public schools.
To be close to his elderly parents, he moved to St. Louis in 1998 and became supervisor of health and physical education at the Jewish Community Center in Chesterfield, Mo. In addition to overseeing facilities and youth sports programs, Holtzman was head coach of the 9- and 10-year-old baseball teams. His assistant was his former prep coach, Ed Mickelson.
Holtzman had batting cages installed in the basement of the Jewish Community Center and during the winter Cardinals players such as Albert Pujols, J.D. Drew, Mike Matheny and John Mabry practiced their hitting there. Pitcher Gene Stechschulte came, too, to get in his throwing.
“They’re terrific with the little kids,” Holtzman told the Post-Dispatch in 2002. “Nobody bothers them as far as autographs, because people know they’re here to work. When they’re done, Pujols or Stechschulte will get in a pickup basketball game or floor hockey game with the little kids.”
Great tribute to an underrated star. How many baseball players can say they won more games than their childhood hero Koufax! I read in SABR bio that Holtzman said he read Marcel Proust’s, Remembrance of Things Past in the original French! That’s remarkable and apparently he was a “staunch advocate of the union” too which I think was rare amongst players at the time. It’s nice to read about players who have multiple interests and talents making their post baseball days so productive and meaningful. I love the continuity of baseball generations in the batting cages Holtzman installed ultimately put to use by the likes of Pujols.
I am glad you appreciate Ken Holtzman’s reading and language skills as much as his pitching skills, Steve. I do, too.
Cubs manager Leo Durocher was the opposite. In 1968, Durocher threatened to send Holtzman to the minors. “I don’t like his attitude,” Leo told The Sporting News. Holtzman said to the publication, “He accused me of being lackadaisical and not being enough of a competitor.” Holtzman said he thought the criticism was unjust and cruel.
The next year. Holtzman tried to bond with Durocher by taking part in his gin rummy card games. According to The Sporting News, “Durocher never has been to college like Holtzman has. Nor does his taste in literature match the pitcher’s. But, in gin rummy, Leo doesn’t have to feel inferior.”
If I ever complete a crossword puzzle, I’m gonna dedicate the accomplishment to Holtzman and if I win a gin rummy round, my hat is off to Leo.
One more Ken Holtzman nugget for you, Steve:
In January 1977, Holtzman told the Associated Press he’d like to be traded by the Yankees to the Brewers. “I’ve always loved Milwaukee,” Holtzman said to the wire service from his home in Illinois. “It’s one of the best baseball cities that ever was.”
Holtzman said his former A’s teammate, third baseman Sal Bando, told him how excited he was about playing for the Brewers in Milwaukee. “If some sort of deal could be worked out, I’d be glad,” Holtzman said.
According to the Associated Press, “The Brewers have expressed interest in Holtzman, and the Yankees are said to have had their eyes on Milwaukee third baseman Don Money.”
Brewers general manager Jim Baumer told the wire service that any deal would have to involve more than Holtzman. “We can’t afford to give up a hitter for a pitcher,” Baumer said. “To make a deal involving those two guys, it would have to be extended. In addition to Holtzman, we’d have to get somebody back who can swing a bat.”
The deal never got made. With Bando at third, the Brewers moved Money to second base in 1977. He spent the remainder of his career with Milwaukee.
Wonderful. Thanks for sharing this Mark. It’s not often that we hear about free agents who want to play in Milwaukee though when they do, they seem to like the city.
Imagine catching a flight in order to make a class, and here I was actually skipping classes just for having a mild hangover. That’s kind of wild.
Another great and interesting write-up about, as Steve says, one of the most underrated players of his era. I think we can all agree that A’s dynasty doesn’t even come close to existing without Holtzman.
Yep, Ken Holtzman’s dedication to attending class was something I could have used in college, too.
On starting and winning Game 7 of the 1973 World Series for the A’s versus the Mets, Holtzman told the San Francisco Examiner, “It was the culmination of everything. I had refined my talents over the years. Now I was the guy picked to win it all.” https://www.retrosheet.org/boxesetc/1973/B10210OAK1973.htm
The A’s were my team as a kid/teen and Ken was definitely a key component of their dynasty back then. Sounds like he was a success off the field as well.
In 1974, when asked about toughest batters he faced, Ken Holtzman told the San Francisco Examiner, “If I had to pick one guy I would never want to see, it would be Dick Allen. Since our first encounter, he has hit me hard. He knows it, and I know it.”
The first time Holtzman faced Allen was July 8, 1966, at Wrigley Field. Allen struck out the first two at-bats versus Holtzman. In his third at-bat, he slammed a three-run home run. https://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/CHN/CHN196607080.shtml?__hstc=205977932.fab20b6ebb624a02d8c3f1f87db1b2fa.1629487036931.1709694329958.1713551787366.2230&__hssc=205977932.4.1714407304567&__hsfp=2651834337
Allen went on to hit 11 career homers versus Holtzman. His career on-base percentage versus Holtzman was .414 (29 hits and 17 walks).
I’m sorry to hear that Ken Holtzman passed away. A great individual and a great cerebral baseball player. I loved those “Swinging A’s teams. To be honest, on weekends, I’m starting to watch more classic baseball games from the past on the internet than games from today. Right now I’m watching the 1970 World Series. Before that though I watched the A’s World Series teams from ’72-’74. It must have been an indescribable experience for a young Ken Holtzman to pitch a gem against Sandy Koufax. I do have a question though. The Kansas City Athletics had the first pick in the 1965 draft, while the Cubs had the sixth pick. In the 4th round however, the Cubs had the 1st pick. Was there some previous trade involving both the Cubs and A’s? Anyway, thanks for another enjoyable read.
I am glad you are getting to watch those classic baseball games, Phillip. Enjoy!
Because the 1965 June amateur draft was baseball’s first, the selection process was quite different from the norm today. Though, by and large, big-league front office personnel did the selecting in each round, only the first round was considered a big-league draft. Subsequent rounds were labeled Class AAA, Class AA, etc.
So, technically, Ken Holtzman in the fourth round was chosen by Dallas-Fort Worth, the Class AA club of the Cubs. That’s why the fourth round selection order was different from the first round selection order.
After the first round was completed, each Class AAA club was entitled to draft a player in the second round and third rounds. According to The Sporting News, “The order of priority was the same as at the major-league level. Consequently the Athletics drew first on behalf of Vancouver and the Mets followed for Buffalo.
“Next came the Class AA draft. Here the routine changed. Instead of following the inverted 1964 major-league finishes, the double-A clubs selected in the reverse order of their own finishes, starting with the Texas League (Dallas-Fort Worth by the Cubs), then the Southern League (Asheville by the Pirates) and the Eastern League (York by the Senators).”
Class AA clubs covered rounds four through seven.
Next came the Class A selections, where the number of selections per club was unlimited. Here again priority was in order of the minor-league clubs’ 1964 finishes. The order of leagues was determined by lot and went: California, Carolina, Northern, Western Carolinas, Northwest, Florida State, New York-Penn and Midwest.
The Holtzman – Monday trade has to be one of the savviest in history – it was what put the A’s over the top after failing against the Orioles in ’71. I always wondered who was behind it. Charlie Finley? He was his own G.M and Whitey Herzog was long gone by then. Incidentally, if you want to see a really dumb scoring decision, Holtzman got an error in game 4 of the ’72 Series when he hit Mike Epstein right in the glove on a drag bunt by Bobby Tolan. Then he blew away Tony Perez on a fastball. For some teason my paste of the link isn’t coming through.
Thanks for the link to the 1972 World Series clip. Fun to see.
According to the Oakland Tribune, it was Charlie Finley who made the Ken Holtzman trade for the A’s. Rick Monday told the newspaper that Finley called him to inform him he’d made the deal.
Nice when a really good ballplayer seems to be a really good guy as well.
Nicely expressed, Ken.
After her father’s death, Robyn Schuster, Ken Holtzman’s oldest daughter, told the St. Louis Jewish Light, “He was raised, and he raised us, with the value that you needed to serve others. And he was generous and supportive of his entire extended family. He always looked for ways that he could help people. He saw it as his mission in life to be there to support his kids and his family members.”