RetroSimba

(Updated Feb. 24, 2019)

The Orioles traded one of their most popular players, Boog Powell, for catcher Dave Duncan.

A 6-foot-4, 250-pound first baseman, Powell slugged 303 home runs in 13 years with the Orioles, won the American League Most Valuable Player Award in 1970 and helped Baltimore to four World Series appearances.

After Powell had his second consecutive subpar season in 1974 (12 home runs, 45 RBI), the Orioles acquired first baseman Lee May from the Astros, making Powell expendable.

On Feb. 25, 1975, the Orioles traded Powell and pitcher Don Hood to the Indians for Duncan and outfield prospect Al McGrew.

According to The Sporting News, the Orioles initially wanted pitching prospect Dennis Eckersley as the player to join Duncan in the deal, but settled for McGrew when the Indians refused to part with Eckersley. Twelve years later, as pitching coach of the Athletics, Duncan would convert a reluctant Eckersley from a starter to a closer, launching him on a path into the National Baseball Hall of Fame.

In going to Cleveland, Powell was reunited with his former Orioles teammate, Frank Robinson, who had become Indians manager, the first African-American to hold that position in the big leagues.

“Boog contributed a heck of a lot to this franchise over the years,” Orioles general manager Frank Cashen said. “I’m truly sorry that he had to go. But when we got Lee May in a trade, he was committed to play first base. That left Boog without a position, and without a job.”

Though the Orioles had three other catchers _ Andy Etchebarren, Elrod Hendricks and Earl Williams _ they anticipated Duncan would win the starting job.

“Despite a .226 career average, the Orioles were impressed with Duncan mainly because of his reputation as a good handler of pitchers,” The Sporting News reported. “His power totals, 67 homers in the last four years, are respectable even if his average could stand a booster shot.”

In a column for the Baltimore Sun, Bob Maisel described Duncan as “a good defensive catcher and handler of pitchers.”

“Duncan should prove the best catcher on the squad,” Maisel wrote. “He has the reputation of being a good competitor, who wants to play, a good man on a club.”

Duncan told the Associated Press he was happy to go to the “strongest team in the Eastern Division.” He said the Orioles had a better chance than the Indians of winning “and winning is what it’s all about.”

The trade worked out better for the Indians than it did for the Orioles. Powell hit .297 with 27 home runs and 86 RBI for the 1975 Indians and was named American League Comeback Player of the Year by The Sporting News. Duncan hit .205 with 12 home runs and 41 RBI for the 1975 Orioles.

After batting .204 with four home runs and 17 RBI in 1976, Duncan was traded by the Orioles to the White Sox after the season.

In 1979, Duncan returned to the Indians as a coach for manager Jeff Torborg. Duncan developed into a respected pitching coach and served on the staff of Cardinals manager Tony La Russa from 1996-2011.