Starting with a walk to Yadier Molina and culminating with a home run by John Mabry, the Cardinals completed the biggest ninth-inning comeback in franchise history.
On May 2, 2005, the Cardinals overcame a six-run deficit by scoring seven runs in the ninth and defeating the Reds, 10-9, at Cincinnati.
The Cardinals sent 12 batters to the plate in that memorable inning and rallied against two relievers on a combination of four singles, two walks, two home runs and an error.
“I’ve never seen this happen,” Cardinals infielder Abraham Nunez told the St. Louis Post-Dispatch. “I hope I don’t see it happen again either.”
The Cardinals never had rallied from six runs behind in the ninth inning. The Reds hadn’t blown a six-run lead in the ninth since June 29, 1952, when an 8-2 advantage turned into a 9-8 loss to the Cubs at Cincinnati. Boxscore
“It’s not easy to give a big-league game away, but that’s what we did,” said Reds reliever Danny Graves after yielding the game-winning home run to Mabry. “It takes 27 outs, not 26 (to win).”
Walks will haunt
With the Reds ahead, 5-3, in the eighth, Graves began to throw in the bullpen in preparation for pitching the ninth. When the Reds scored four in the eighth, however, manager Dave Miley decided to save his closer and instead sent David Weathers to pitch the ninth, entrusting the 15-year big-league veteran with a 9-3 lead.
“The only way they could get back in the game is if we walked guys _ and I walked guys,” Weathers said to The Cincinnati Post.
Weathers walked the first two batters, Molina and Nunez. David Eckstein singled, loading the bases with none out.
“I was just all over the place,” Weathers said of his pitches.
Still, he almost escaped the jam unscathed.
Roger Cedeno struck out.
When Albert Pujols followed with a grounder to shortstop Rich Aurilia, it appeared the Reds might turn a game-ending double play.
Aurilia fielded the ball cleanly and tossed to D’Angelo Jimenez for the forceout of Eckstein at second base. Jimenez, however, couldn’t complete the turn and Pujols was safe at first. Molina scooted home from third on the play, making the score, 9-4.
The Cardinals remained alive, with Nunez on third, Pujols on first and two outs.
Reggie Sanders, the ex-Red, then singled, plating Nunez, moving Pujols to second and making the score 9-5.
Said Weathers: “It’s embarrassing … No excuses. That’s just bad pitching.”
Edmonds delivers
Miley lifted Weathers and replaced him with Graves, who had converted all eight of his save chances that season.
The first batter Graves faced was Jim Edmonds.
Hoping to catch the Reds by surprise, “I was thinking about bunting, honestly,” Edmonds told the Associated Press.
The slugger changed his mind, though, and decided to swing away.
Graves’ third pitch to Edmonds was a hanging breaking ball.
Edmonds belted it for a three-run home run, making the score 9-8.
Reds unravel
The Reds were reeling, but the Cardinals still trailed with the bases empty and two outs.
“Nobody wants to make that last out,” said Mabry. “That’s what it comes down to.”
Following Edmonds was Mark Grudzielanek. He smacked a grounder directly at Sean Casey. The ball ricocheted off the first baseman’s arm for a two-base error.
That brought up Mabry, who started the game at third base in place of Scott Rolen, who was nursing a back strain.
With the tying run at second, “I was just trying to drive the run home by staying inside the ball and driving it to the big part of the ballpark,” Mabry said.
Mabry did even better. He hit the first pitch over the center-field fence, a two-run homer, giving the Cardinals a 10-9 lead.
“That’s why baseball’s a beautiful game,” Mabry said.
A rattled Graves yielded singles to Molina and Nunez before retiring Eckstein on a fly out to right.
As Graves left the mound, the crowd, estimated at fewer than 10,000 in the ninth, was “booing at the top of their lungs,” The Post reported.
“To have that happen just makes us feel really small,” Graves said to Post columnist Lonnie Wheeler.
Finish the job
With closer Jason Isringhausen unavailable, Cardinals manager Tony La Russa chose Julian Tavarez to pitch the bottom of the ninth.
The first batter, Joe Randa, singled. Aurilia tried a sacrifice bunt, but Randa was forced out at second.
Tavarez then plunked Jason LaRue with a pitch, advancing Aurilia to second.
The drama finally ended when Austin Kearns grounded into a double play. Boxscore
“We have no baseball luck, I guess,” said Graves, “and in this game you do need a lot of luck along with skill.”
Three weeks later, Graves ran out of luck with the Reds. They released him.
Previously: How David Bell rang up a special Cardinals home run
Previously: Jim Edmonds was dandy for Cardinals in 2004 NLCS
Previously: Slugging, fielding give Jim Edmonds hope for Hall of Fame
RetroSimba 
I have a friend who is a Cardinal fan in Ohio, like myself. He was at this game with his family. I remember watching it on TV and relishing the huge rally, especially being in Reds country. It was raining in the final inning at Cincy, so my Redbird fan friend and his family left early and missed the monster comeback!
Thank you for the insights. I had forgotten about the rain. I was watching on TV as well and it was fun to feel that growing sense throughout the ninth that the Cardinals could do something quite special.
Sure, you’re welcome. A great memory for Cardinal fans, especially those of us cursed by living around jealous and angry Reds fans. Another game I recall was when Darren Bragg hit a 9th inning walk off homer to beat the Reds, 2-1 I think, around 1999 or 2000. It barely got over the wall. But back then, almost any homer in Busch II was legit.
One of the things that has taken some key action out of the game are the lower walls in almost all of the new retro parks. The parks of the 60s-early 90s or so tended to have 10-12 foot walls or higher. This turned a lot of balls that are homers now into doubles or triples – AND it kept balls from constantly bouncing over the short fences nowadays for ground rule doubles.
I think an interesting study would be to see how ground rule doubles have increased dramatically the last 20 years due to the newer parks’ lower fences. It really stops the action imo. A triple or a throw out at third is one of the more extended, exciting plays in baseball you don’t see as much anymore.
Of course, they like the lower fences that make catches look more spectacular now. Cheapens the game, imo.