In their two matchups against one another, Randy Johnson, as expected, pitched like a Hall of Famer, but Jose Jimenez unexpectedly was better.
On June 25, 1999, Jimenez pitched a no-hitter for the Cardinals, beating Johnson and the Diamondbacks, 1-0, at Phoenix.
Two weeks later, on July 5, 1999, Jimenez pitched a two-hitter, beating Johnson and the Diamondbacks, 1-0, at St. Louis.
The outcomes were surprising because the Diamondbacks led the National League in runs scored in 1999 and Jimenez was battered by nearly every other opponent.
Prized prospect
Jimenez, a right-hander from the Dominican Republic, signed as an amateur free agent with the Cardinals in October 1991 when he was 18. He spent his first three seasons as a professional in the Dominican Summer League before the Cardinals brought him to the United States in 1995 to pitch in their minor-league system.
His breakout season in the minors occurred with Class AA Arkansas in 1998 when he was 15-6 in 26 starts. Jimenez credited Arkansas pitching coach Rich Folkers, a former Cardinals reliever, with helping him develop an effective sinker, the St. Louis Post-Dispatch reported.
The Cardinals rewarded Jimenez by bringing him to the big leagues in September 1998. After making his major-league debut in relief against the Reds, Jimenez made three starts and was the winning pitcher in each, beating the Pirates and Brewers on the road and the Expos at home.
With his 3-0 record and 2.95 ERA in four appearances for the 1998 Cardinals, Jimenez was regarded a special prospect. When the Cardinals tried to acquire second baseman Fernando Vina from the Brewers after the 1998 season, they were told they’d have to give up Jimenez and pitcher Manny Aybar, according to the Post-Dispatch. The Cardinals declined.
Mix and match
Jimenez, 25, opened the 1999 season as a Cardinals starter, but the success he experienced in 1998 didn’t carry over.
He entered his June start at Phoenix with a 3-7 record and 6.69 ERA. Matched against Johnson, the left-hander who was at the peak of his Hall of Fame career, the game figured to be lopsided in favor of the Diamondbacks.
The Diamondbacks led the National League in hitting at .287 coming into the game.
Relying on a mix of pitches, Jimenez was in command from the start.
“I was throwing very well,” he said to the Arizona Republic. “I was hitting my spots. I’ve been working on my mechanics, my sinker.”
Said Diamondbacks outfielder Luis Gonzalez: “His fastball was moving really well. His changeup was effective. He was nasty.”
Jimenez yielded a one-out walk to Steve Finley in the second, but the next batter grounded into a double play. In the third, Jimenez hit Andy Fox with a pitch, but retired the next two batters to end the inning.
“All his pitches were working to all parts of the plate,” said Cardinals manager Tony La Russa.
Dueling shutouts
In the sixth, Fox hit a drive to right-center, but right fielder Eric Davis reached down, snared the sinking liner and held onto the ball as he rolled onto the ground.
The Diamondbacks got their last baserunner in the seventh when Gonzalez drew a one-out walk, but Jimenez coaxed the next batter to ground into a double play.
“His ball was moving all over the place,” Johnson said. “He was in control. He made a lot of our hitters frustrated.”
Johnson was tough on the Cardinals as well. He retired the first nine batters in a row before Joe McEwing led off the fourth with a double. The Cardinals got doubles from Edgar Renteria in the fifth and David Howard in the sixth, but couldn’t score.
In the ninth, with the game scoreless, Johnson issued one-out walks to Darren Bragg and Mark McGwire. After Davis struck out, Thomas Howard hit a broken-bat single to left, scoring Bragg.
Flying high
In the bottom of the ninth, Fox led off and struck out. David Dellucci batted for Johnson and looped a liner toward right-center.
“I thought it would drop in,” Dellucci said.
Davis darted toward the ball, caught it near his shoe tops, tumbled and held on for the out.
“I know he’s a good outfielder,” said Dellucci, a teammate of Davis in 1997 with the Orioles. “Anybody else, it might have been in there.”
Jimenez completed the no-hitter by getting Tony Womack to ground out to second. [Boxscore and video of last out]
“This is something special,” Jimenez said. “I feel great. I feel like I want to fly.”
The no-hitter was the first by a Cardinal since Bob Forsch accomplished the feat against the Expos on Sept. 26, 1983.
Jimenez struck out eight. Johnson, who yielded five hits and two walks, struck out 14. Video of game
Snake bit
Jimenez got one more win for the Cardinals. When the Diamondbacks came to St. Louis, he retired the first 13 batters in order before Finley doubled with one out in the fifth. The only other hit Jimenez allowed was a single by Fox in the sixth.
Once again, Thomas Howard drove in the lone run. His single against Johnson scored McGwire from second with two outs in the fourth.
Jimenez walked one and struck out nine. Johnson gave up four hits and four walks, striking out 12. Boxscore
Cardinals pitching coach Dave Duncan said Jimenez “was relaxed and let it all flow. When he has pitched good, that’s the way he has looked.”
Jimenez never found the groove again with the Cardinals. He finished the 1999 season with a 5-14 record and 5.85 ERA. He was 2-0 versus the Diamondbacks and 3-14 against everyone else.
On Nov. 16, 1999, the Cardinals traded three pitchers _ Jimenez, Aybar and Rich Croushore _ and infielder Brent Butler to the Rockies for pitchers Darryl Kile, Dave Veres and Luther Hackman.
The Rockies made Jimenez a reliever and in four seasons with them he was 15-23 with 102 saves and a 4.13 ERA. He had 41 saves for the 2002 Rockies.
Jimenez became a free agent after the 2003 season, signed with the Indians and finished his big-league career with them in 2004.
In seven big-league seasons, Jimenez was 24-44 with 110 saves and a 4.92 ERA.
This game was one of the few bright spots in a disappointing season. Jose was no hall of famer but he did have his well deserved moment of glory. With Colorado, having to pitch in Coors Field, he put up some decent numbers. For a time, he held the record for most saves in a season. And right now, he has the second most saves all-time for the Rockies. Let’s not forget the great plays by Eric Davis. I didn’t know the video of the game was available. Hearing the voice of the legendary Joe Garigiola is always a treat.
Thanks for the info. I didn’t know Jose Jimenez ranks second in career saves among Rockies. In reviewing the list, I was surprised to see the Rockies’ career saves leader is Brian Fuentes, who finished his playing days with a short, unsuccessful stint with the Cardinals.
Brian Fuentes was absolutely terrible in Oakland and was run out of town. He is ranked as one of the A’s fan’s least favorite players to this day.
I see that, overall with the Athletics,, Brian Fuentes was 4-10 with a 4.64 ERA. No wonder they released him.
Jimenez was an intriguing player. Aside from those two games vs. the D-Backs, he wasn’t very impressive during his short time with the Cards. But how did he end up being so effective as a closer in Colorado?! Look at all the guys that have struggled pitching at Coors Field, then Jimenez posts an ERA of 4.13 over four seasons. That would have to be the equivalent of a 2.00 ERA anywhere else lol. It would be interesting to see his Home/Away splits during his time as a Rockie.
An interesting note, though, is that the Rockies experimented with moving him back into the starting rotation at the end of 2003. I think the results were mixed, then they let him go after the season. Jimenez then signed with the Indians and they planned on having him fill-in as their closer until Bob Wickman returned from elbow surgery around the All-Star Break. Jose struggled and the Tribe released him in early July. He didn’t catch on with anyone else in ’04, but the following season he went to spring training with Arizona as a non-roster invitee. He was released before the regular season started and that was the end of his Major League career.
Thanks for all the insights.
According to The Sporting News, Jose Jimenez struggled with his pitching mechanics and had trouble “throwing consecutive pitches from the same arm slot.” When his mechanics were good, his hard sinker was effective. So, too, a slider with wicked movement. When the mechanics were bad, his confidence faltered and so did his results. That might help explain why he was inconsistent despite a lot of talent.