Hal Smith, a Cardinals catcher in the 1950s, had a significant role in the club’s success in the 1980s.
On Oct. 21, 1981, the Cardinals got minor-league outfielder Willie McGee from the Yankees for pitcher Bob Sykes. The Cardinals made the trade on the recommendation of Smith, a Cardinals scout, who watched McGee play for the Yankees’ Nashville farm club and liked what he saw.
McGee went on to become one of the Cardinals’ best and most popular players, using his hitting, fielding and speed to help them win three National League pennants and a World Series title.
Pining for pinstripes
McGee was 17 and recently graduated from high school in 1976 when the White Sox selected him in the June amateur baseball draft. McGee was chosen in the seventh round, just after the Tigers took Ozzie Smith and just before the Red Sox selected Wade Boggs.
If McGee had signed with the White Sox, he eventually might have made his debut in the majors for Tony La Russa, who became White Sox manager in August 1979. Instead, McGee decided to attend community college.
The decision appeared to be shrewd when the Yankees took him in the first round of the secondary phase of the draft in January 1977, “but, unwise to the ways of negotiating contracts, he wound up signing for less than the White Sox had offered him,” the St. Louis Post-Dispatch reported.
“I probably could have got more if I knew what I was doing,” McGee said.
In 1978, his second season in the Yankees’ system, McGee, a natural right-handed batter, started switch-hitting.
He was considered a promising prospect when he got to Class AA Nashville in 1980, but in July he suffered a broken jaw and was limited to 78 games for the season. McGee hit .283. Designated hitter Buck Showalter, the future big-league manager, led Nashville in batting average (.324) and hits (178) in 1980.
Odd man out
The Yankees put McGee on their 40-man big-league winter roster after the 1980 season, but in December they signed free-agent outfielder Dave Winfield and needed to open a spot for him.
McGee was one of two players the Yankees considered dropping from their roster. The other was his best friend on the Nashville team, Ted Wilborn, a switch-hitting outfielder who played briefly with the Blue Jays and Yankees.
Yankees vice president for baseball operations Bill Bergesch, a former Cardinals minor-league executive who signed Bob Gibson to his first pro contract, told the New York Daily News, “We liked Willie. We considered him a fine prospect, but our minor-league people liked the other player (Wilborn) better.”
McGee said to The Tennessean newspaper, “Somebody had to go and I was the least experienced.”
By being reassigned outright to Nashville, McGee was frozen on the minor-league roster and couldn’t be recalled by the Yankees.
Good report card
McGee, Wilborn and Don Mattingly formed the Nashville outfield in 1981. McGee led Nashville in batting (.322) and had 24 stolen bases. Mattingly batted .316 and led the club in hits (173). Wilborn hit .295 and had 43 steals.
Hal Smith, the Cardinals’ starting catcher from 1956-60, was scouting the Nashville team extensively because the Yankees were looking to make a deal for Cardinals pitcher Bob Sykes.
During the 1981 season, “a proposed trade with the Yankees that would have involved Sykes fell through,” the Post-Dispatch reported, but the clubs were hopeful of reviving the deal after the season.
Cardinals executive Joe McDonald said the trade evolved when he received a report from Smith about McGee.
“Smith scouted Willie and turned in a good report,” McDonald said to the Post-Dispatch. “We liked his speed and we liked his bat.”
The Yankees looked to trade McGee to get something in return rather than lose him in the Rule 5 draft of players left unprotected on minor-league rosters.
In exploring potential deals, Bergesch told the New York Daily News, “There wasn’t a whole lot of interest in him” except from the Cardinals.
The trade of Sykes for McGee was made the same day the Yankees played the Dodgers in Game 2 of the 1981 World Series and drew little attention.
As good as advertised
McGee was placed on the Cardinals’ 40-man big-league winter roster.
Though he never had played above the Class AA level, he impressed the Cardinals at spring training in 1982.
“He speaks only when spoken to and goes largely unnoticed in the clubhouse,” the Post-Dispatch noted, “but he has skills that have marked him as a soon-to-be major leaguer.”
“Got a quick bat,” said Cardinals manager Whitey Herzog. “It’s unusual to see a young hitter with a quick bat from both sides of the plate.”
Batting from the right side, McGee dazzled by dashing from the plate to first base in 3.9 seconds.
At Yankees training camp, Sykes, weakened by shoulder ailments, was sent to the minors. He’d never pitch in a big-league game for the Yankees.
Upset about receiving what they considered damaged goods, the Yankees wanted the trade voided. “They think they’re going to get McGee back,” Herzog told the Post-Dispatch, “and they’re not.”
Making an impact
McGee began the 1982 season at Louisville. “I thought I was going to play the full year in triple-A to get some experience because I hadn’t played there before,” he told The Sporting News.
The plan changed when Cardinals outfielder David Green tore his right hamstring and was placed on the disabled list on May 8. The Cardinals called up McGee, who had hit .291 in 13 games with Louisville.
From the start, the rookie played like he belonged. He hit .378 for the Cardinals in May and .349 in June.
“I certainly didn’t think he’d be able to come up here and handle the pitching like he has,” Herzog told The Sporting News.
For the season, McGee hit .296 and swiped 24 bases for the Cardinals. He hit .308 in the National League Championship Series versus the Braves, and was the standout of World Series Game 3, with two home runs and two spectacular catches against the Brewers. Boxscore and Video.
On Jan. 24, 1983, the Cardinals traded outfielder Stan Javier and infielder Bobby Meacham to the Yankees for outfielder Bob Helson and pitchers Steve Fincher and Marty Mason. The Post-Dispatch reported the deal was to appease Yankees owner George Steinbrenner, who held hard feelings toward the Cardinals for sending Sykes in exchange for McGee 15 months earlier.
RetroSimba 
I recall that the A’s acquired him as a “rent a player” for Felix Jose (Remember that name?) as a switch-hitting option off the bench and maybe even a late-inning defensive replacement. Unfortunately, he didn’t win a ring as the team fell to the Reds and that nasty Jose Rijo in the WS.
Thanks, Gary. You are correct. Side note to that: Willie McGee still had enough at-bats to win the 1990 National League batting title, even though he spent the last month of the season with the A’s. Here’s my story on McGee’s trade to Oakland: https://retrosimba.com/2015/08/27/why-the-cardinals-traded-willie-mcgee-to-athletics/
Too bad we couldn’t pick up Wade Boggs and make a clean sweep, but two outta three isn’t bad. You really can’t say enough about Willie McGee, both as an individual and as a player. I do however, have a question. Is there any truth to the story that Willie McGee himself called up the Cardinals to ask them if it was true that he now was in their organization? Thanks.
In the Oct. 17, 1982, New York Times, McGee, recalling his trade from the Yankees to the Cardinals, told columnist Dave Anderson, “I picked up the paper one day at home (in Richmond, Calif.) and read about it in transactions. The Yankees never called me. The Cardinals never called me. After two weeks of not hearing from either of them, I finally called the Cardinals.”
The Stan Javier trade to the Yankees after the fact to appease Steinbrenner was also to secure his “No” vote on retaining Commissioner Bowie Kuhn.
Thanks for the insight.
We would run into Willie at our apartment complex and at the 7-11 on Olive at 270 back in the day. He was always friendly to us kids.
We were lucky to live in Westgate Apartments. We were surrounded by the Cardinals that lived there. Willie, Tommy Herr, Steve Braun, Doug Bair, Glenn Brummer and Bob Forsch (who lived in the subdivision directly behind the complex’s tennis courts). There were some football Cards there too…Mel Gray was one of the best to us.
It was a fun time to be a kid there back then. Brummer was the best, most down to earth guy who would play catch with us kids.
Thanks for sharing with us your remembrances of those wonderful encounters.
Nice read here- I had heard some of these details but not all so glad to read this. seems like these days the Cardinals are on the other end of the equation and “leak” great talent to other teams. I’m not sure why it keeps repeating recently, but it’s a major red flag that Mo needs to be held accountable for.
Thanks for reading and for commenting. I appreciate your take on things.
Why did the Cardinals trade him in 1990?
Thanks for asking. Willie McGee was going to become a free agent after the 1990 season and the Cardinals didn’t think they could re-sign him. The Cardinals figured it would be better to trade him and get players in return rather than just lose him to free agency. Here is my story on his trade to the A’s: https://retrosimba.com/2015/08/27/why-the-cardinals-traded-willie-mcgee-to-athletics/