Rescued from the Reds farm system, where he languished as a reliever, Kurt Kepshire developed into a starter for a Cardinals contender.
On Dec. 6, 1982, Kepshire was chosen by the Cardinals in the Rule 5 draft after being left off the Reds’ big-league winter roster.
The Cardinals might have kept Kepshire in a relief role as well if not for a fluke incident involving an Army tank.
Smashing success
A right-hander, Kepshire was a standout pitcher his senior season at Bridgeport Central Catholic High School in Connecticut. Five days before he was to start in a state quarterfinal playoff game, a careless classmate accidently pounded Kepshire’s pitching hand with a sledgehammer, breaking his index and middle fingers, the St. Louis Post-Dispatch reported.
“My coach said, ‘You can’t pitch,’ ” Kepshire recalled to The Sporting News. “I said, ‘Watch me warm up.’ “
Given the start, Kepshire struck out 17 and got the win. A few days later, he started and won the state championship game. “I pitched in pain, I’ll tell you that,” Kepshire said to The Sporting News. “It was pride. I love to pitch and I love a challenge.”
Kepshire enrolled at the University of New Haven and signed with the Reds after being selected in the 25th round of the 1979 amateur draft.
Used primarily as a reliever, Kepshire pitched four seasons in the Reds organization before he was drafted by the Cardinals on the recommendation of their Louisville farm club manager, Joe Frazier, according to the Post-Dispatch.
Ready, aim, fire
Assigned to the Cardinals’ Class AA Arkansas team in 1983, Kepshire made 19 relief appearances before being promoted to Class AAA Louisville.
Soon after Kepshire arrived in Louisville, Jim Fregosi, who had replaced Frazier as manager, approached him an hour before a game versus Omaha and asked if he could start. “I was shocked,” Kepshire told the Louisville Courier-Journal.
Fregosi made the request because Louisville’s scheduled starting pitcher, Todd Worrell, sprained his back “when he slipped off a tank that he was inspecting” while visiting a military museum at Fort Knox earlier that day, the Louisville newspaper reported.
Under the headline “Tanks A Lot,” the Courier-Journal reported that Kepshire pitched six scoreless innings in his surprise start and got the win in Louisville’s 2-0 triumph over Omaha.
“He threw great,” catcher Tom Nieto told the Louisville newspaper. “His fastball was just taking off and he was spotting pitches and keeping the ball down, going right at them.”
In 21 appearances, including 10 starts, for Louisville in 1983, Kepshire was 6-2.
Big-league stuff
Sent back to Louisville to begin the 1984 season, Kepshire was in the starting rotation from the first day. Relying on a fastball and slider, he was 7-5 in 16 starts when the Cardinals called him to the big leagues in July to replace John Stuper in the starting rotation.
“Kepshire wasn’t ready (for the majors) at the beginning of the season, but he’s come into his own,” Fregosi told the Post-Dispatch. “He has a better idea of how to pitch.”
Making his debut in a start against the Giants the day after his 25th birthday, Kepshire allowed one run in 8.1 innings and got the win. “He challenges those guys,” Herzog told The Sporting News. “He’s got guts. I love it.” Boxscore
A month later, Kepshire prevailed in a start against Nolan Ryan and the Astros. Boxscore
Praising Kepshire for his willingness to pitch inside to batters, Herzog told The Sporting News, “He’s got nerve. Of all the kid pitchers, he’s going to be the best.”
The rookie capped his season with shutouts of the Cubs and Expos, finishing 6-5 with a 3.30 ERA. Boxscore and Boxscore
Cardinals pitching coach Mike Roarke said Kepshire “made tremendous progress” since spring training and adjusted to a change in his delivery that enabled him “to throw downhill,” the Post-Dispatch reported.
Falling out
Kepshire went to spring training in 1985 assured of a spot in a Cardinals starting rotation with Joaquin Andujar, John Tudor and Danny Cox. “He goes after hitters and he doesn’t rattle easily,” Herzog told the Post-Dispatch in March 1985. “Right now, I’m looking at him as a good No. 3 starter.”
After beating the Pirates on Aug. 15, Kepshire had a season record of 9-6, but then staggered down the stretch, winning one of his next six starts.
In his last start, Sept. 14 versus the Cubs, Kepshire threw 14 pitches and 13 were out of the strike zone. After walking the bases loaded, he was lifted with the count 1-and-0 count on the next batter. Boxscore
Kepshire finished the season 10-9. His wins were important for a division champion that finished just three games ahead of the Mets, but he walked more (71) than he struck out (67) and gave up more hits (155) than innings pitched (153.1). The Cardinals left him off their playoff roster.
“I still think he can be a hell of a pitcher,” Herzog told the Post-Dispatch. “He needs an off-speed pitch, and he’s got a good one in the bullpen, but he can’t get it over in a game.”
Kepshire said to the newspaper, “I stunk it up the second half of (the) season. That’s my fault. It was a mental thing. I was in a rut.”
Different direction
The Cardinals tried to trade Kepshire after the season but didn’t get any takers, the Post-Dispatch reported.
“The Cardinals are dead wrong on me,” Kepshire said to the Springfield (Ill.) State Journal-Register. “I can throw strikes.”
He opened the 1986 season with them, made two appearances, including a start, and was demoted to Louisville.
“I don’t ever see myself coming back here,” Kepshire said to the Post-Dispatch as he left St. Louis.
Herzog responded, “If he has that attitude, he’ll never come back.”
Kepshire spent what he described to United Press International as “a miserable year” in the Cardinals farm system in 1986, signed with the Cleveland Indians after the season, got released in spring training, pitched in Mexico and in the minors for Expos and Twins affiliates, but never got back to the majors.
His career record with the Cardinals was 16-15, including marks of 4-1 against the Cubs and 3-0 versus the Giants.
RetroSimba 
It’s too bad he couldn’t work out the control problems that he had. There were times it seemed that he was going to have a good career. For some reason or another remembering the two consecutive shutouts he had made me think of Bob Sykes who also had two consecutive shutouts in 1980.
Thanks, Phillip. You are right about the control problems. The year before, in 1984 with the Cardinals, it was just the opposite for Kurt Kepshire: He had 71 strikeouts and 44 walks.
Kepshire pitched 216.2 innings in 1984 (107.2 for Louisville and 109 for the Cardinals). That was by far the most innings he pitched in one season. He also pitched in winter ball in Puerto Rico before reporting to spring training in 1985. Makes one wonder if all the work had anything to do with his command issues late in 1985.
Your Bob Sykes item prompts me to mention that Sykes had 6 wins, 3 of them shutouts, for the 1980 Cardinals. Two of those shutouts came against the Phillies, who became World Series champions that year.
An interesting ball player and story, Mark. I don’t recall him, but we do see these instances where a guy simply can’t develop a suitable alternative to his go-to pitch. It happens, and it’s a shame in his instance.
Thanks for the astute comment, Bruce.
An aside: Kurt Kepshire had quite a duel in a start matched against John Denny of the Phillies at Veterans Stadium on Aug. 10, 1984. Kepshire and Denny each pitched eight scoreless innings but neither got a decision: https://www.retrosheet.org/boxesetc/1984/B08100PHI1984.htm
With the Cardinals, Kepshire made seven starts vs. the Phillies and was 1-1 with a 3.32 ERA.
Thanks for the retrosheet link, Mark. That’s a cool site.
Kurt Kepshire. I’m like walkingoffthe chessboard in that I had never heard of him, but I recognize that 1985 Topps set. That was the set I got my first Dwight Gooden card from. I think Topps issued one the previous years, in the Topps Traded set, but I never had that one. Anyway, as always Mark, a very interesting write up about an inspiring player. I like that he came inside on batters and refused to give up, even in high school with broken fingers. I read somewhere about baseball injuries being two kinds – 1) so bad you can’t play and 2) not bad enough to prevent you from playing. I took that quote to heart when I read it and still do when I contemplate whether or not to call in sick to work. Kepshire strikes me as someone who might have liked to prolong his career and pitch in Japan.
Thanks, Steve. Like you, there are players I remember more from their baseball card than from their playing days. The lasting power of baseball cards is a true marvel.
A tidbit for a Milwaukee buff: Kurt Kepshire’s last season as a player was in 1989 with the Portland (Ore.) Beavers. His manager was Phil Roof, one of three players (Hank Aaron and Felipe Alou being the others) who played for both the Milwaukee Braves and the Milwaukee Brewers.
Sorry to be a wet blanket, but what does “throwing downhill” mean? Who are the pitchers that don’t throw downhill? I seem to remember John Candelaria was pretty successful throwing side-hill. Kepshire’s low K percentage in the minors tells me he was a sinkerballer. Those guys frequently just lose it. A decade ago my favorite team couldn’t stop talking about the “bowling ball” heavy sinker of the new guy they discovered. And at 6’8”, he was some kind of downhill. But after 20 innings he was never heard from again.
Thanks for the good insights and for the good question.
The St. Louis Post-Dispatch article reported that Kurt Kepshire had adjusted to “a more stand-up delivery, which enabled him, as coach Mike Roarke said, ‘to throw downhill.’ ”
I should have included the adjustment to a “more stand-up delivery” in my story to help explain the “throw downhill” part.
Better yet, I probably should have just written that Roarke praised Kepshire for making a change in his delivery, and left it at that, because you are correct: pitching off a mound requires a pitcher to, essentially, throw downhill and Roarke’s words were just coach-speak to illustrate the more erect posture in the delivery.
An aside: The Sept. 27, 1984, Post-Dispatch story with the insight about the “stand-up delivery” and “throwing downhill” was about Kepshire throwing 160 pitches in a shutout of the Expos.